A brief preface: I single out the Mormon church in this post for two reasons; because of it’s members’ recent involvement in efforts to deny gays the right to marry (Cali’s prop 8), and because I was raised Mormon. I certainly do not want to convey that I think Mormons are the only religion opposed to gay marriage nor am I attempting to paint them as the root of the problem.
Gay marriage is a touchy subject for a lot of people. Religion seems to have the longest list of issues with the idea, which is fair. In 2008, proposition 8 was put forth to take away the rights of gays to marry in California. Members of the Mormon church (The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints) donated more than $44 million to the cause1. While I respect a person’s right to donate to whatever cause they see fit, I just have to ask, why? What do these people hope to accomplish by denying gay people the same rights? It’s certainly not stopping people from being gay. It is merely depriving a group of people the right to legally bind themselves to whomever they see fit – male or female.
A cornerstone of Mormon belief is the notion of free will; the agency to make our own choices. In the 1838, the Mormons were driven out of Missouri because of their actions, which were a direct result of their beliefs. They were forced to migrate westward to escape persecution and so they could practice their religion as they saw fit. Are Mormons of today forgetting that the ill-treatment of their ancestors was because they were different? Their own 11th Article of Faith states:
We claim the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience, and allow all men the same privilege, let them worship how, where, or what they may.
According to this, Mormons do believe I should be allowed the privilege to worship in any way I please, even if that means it contradicts what they believe.
So why can’t gay people be allowed the same rights? Why can’t we be afforded the same privilege to legally bind ourselves to whomever we choose, male or female? The freedom of religion gives you the right to exclude gay people from your “loving” community and deny them certain sacraments or privileges. It does not give you permission to deny the rights of others who do not share your beliefs.
I have yet to hear a valid reason for not allowing gays to legally marry that isn’t somehow founded in religious belief. While I respect your right to practice your religion and believe what you want to believe, you must also respect my right not to. I don’t have to believe or practice your religion, nor do I have to adhere to or be governed by it’s standards. There is supposed to be a separation of church and state2. The idea of equality is that everyone, regardless of sex, religion, race, etc, is entitled to the same rights. So, as an American, I have the right to get married… but shouldn’t I be able to choose with whom I enter this commitment? Of course, you say, as long as it’s a man, you have the freedom to choose. Why are there stipulations for me because I am attracted to the same sex?
I’ve often heard the argument that to allow gay people to marry would destroy the sanctity of marriage. Destroy the sanctity of marriage? Why are gay couples held to a higher standard? Why not launch a campaign against Las Vegas wedding chapels with Elvis as the officiator? What about the ease with which a couple can divorce? If we are going to pick apart the sanctity of a union, shouldn’t we put straight couples under a microscope as well? Why do they get the green light just because they have the magic combination of one man and one woman? It does not automatically make a marriage more good or right or okay; It is not an indication of a more wholesome link between two people.
Let’s be brutally honest here for a minute. Doesn’t a lot of it have to do with the gross-out factor? You don’t get it, so it creeps you out and gives you the heebie-jeebies worse than that time you watched the neighbor’s kid eat that caterpillar. I know that’s how a lot of straight people feel about gay people (whether or not they are willing to admit it), because that’s how the straight thing makes me feel. Honestly. Okay, not seeing straight people kiss or be affectionate – clearly, since I’ve been exposed to this my entire life and because this is also the vast majority, I have become somewhat comfortable with this. But the idea of being at all sexual with a man has that same creep-out effect on me. It always has on some level (even while I was still dating men) and does much more now that I’m openly and exclusively gay. But yeah, eww. See? We’re not as different as you think! We both get grossed out at the idea of intimacy with one of the sexes. I’m just pretty far down the gay end of the spectrum, so perhaps people near the straight end are those that can relate to that icky feeling.
But here’s the thing… that icky feeling doesn’t mean it’s wrong for everyone. It just means it may not be right for you. We have acknowledged countless ways that every person is unique. We also have an amazing gift of freedom and a plethora of rights allowing us to express, even celebrate our uniqueness. It’s up to us to allow one another to do that to the fullest, whether or not it jives with our personal religious beliefs.
2- I say, “supposed to be” because I realize there are many areas where religion has wiggled in; In God We Trust on all US currency, …one nation, under God… in our country’s pledge of allegiance, …so help you God as an oath of honesty, to name a few